| Head Coaches | HC1: Bill Belichick HC2: Vince Lombardi |
| Quarterbacks | QB1: Tom Brady QB2: Joe Montana QB3: Peyton Manning |
| Running Backs | RB1: Walter Payton RB2: Jim Brown RB3: Barry Sanders RB4: Emmitt Smith |
| Fullback | FB: Franco Harris |
| Wide Receivers | WR1: Jerry Rice WR2: Randy Moss WR3: Terrell Owens WR4: Larry Fitzgerald WR5: Calvin Johnson |
| Tight Ends | TE1: Tony Gonzalez TE2: Antonio Gates TE3: Shannon Sharpe |
| Offensive Tackles | OT1: Anthony Muñoz OT2: Jonathan Ogden OT3: Joe Thomas OT4: Jim Parker |
| Offensive Guards | OG1: John Hannah OG2: Gene Upshaw OG3: Bruce Matthews OG4: Larry Allen |
| Centers | C1: Jim Otto C2: Mike Webster |
| Defensive Ends | DE1: Reggie White DE2: Bruce Smith DE3: Deacon Jones DE4: J.J. Watt |
| Defensive Tackles | DT1: Joe Greene DT2: Warren Sapp DT3: Alan Page DT4: Bob Lilly |
| Outside Linebackers | OLB1: Lawrence Taylor OLB2: Jack Ham OLB3: Derrick Brooks OLB4: Derrick Thomas |
| Middle Linebackers | MLB1: Ray Lewis MLB2: Dick Butkus MLB3: Jack Lambert |
| Cornerbacks | CB1: Deion Sanders CB2: Charles Woodson CB3: Rod Woodson CB4: Mel Blount CB5: Champ Bailey |
| Safeties | S1: Ronnie Lott S2: Ed Reed S3: Brian Dawkins S4: Troy Polamalu |
| Kicker | K: Adam Vinatieri |
| Punter | P: Ray Guy |
| Return Specialists | RS1: Devin Hester RS2: Deion Sanders |
Team was finalized on August 1, 2019. Voters were not allowed to vote for players who played for their team or coaches who coached for their team.
