| Manager | Terry Francona |
| Starting Pitchers | SP1: Justin Verlander* SP2: Clayton Kershaw* SP3: Randy Johnson* SP4: Roy Halladay* SP5: Max Scherzer* |
| Relief/Closing Pitchers | RP1: Mariano Rivera~ RP2: Craig Kimbrel* RP3: Kenley Jansen* RP4: Billy Wagner* RP5: Francisco Rodríguez* RP6: Joe Nathan* RP7: Aroldis Chapman RP8: Jonathan Papelbon |
| Catcher | Buster Posey |
| First Baseman | Albert Pujols |
| Second Baseman | Jose Altuve~ |
| Shortstop | Derek Jeter~ |
| Third Baseman | Alex Rodriguez |
| Bench Infielders | Miguel Cabrera* Adrián Beltré* |
| Right Fielder | Ichiro Suzuki |
| Center Fielder | Mike Trout |
| Left Fielder | Barry Bonds~ |
| Bench Outfielders | Aaron Judge* Carlos Beltrán* |
| Designated Hitter | David Ortiz~ |
~Denotes Unanimous Starter
*Denotes Unanimous Selection (Player/Coach can be selected by all voters and still become a backup if they did not receive enough 1st place votes)
Team was finalized on January 23, 2025.

