| The Gridiron Player of the Year | Myles Garrett | Defensive End | Cleveland Browns |
| Best Quarterback | *Matthew Stafford | Los Angeles Rams |
| Best Running Back | Jahmyr Gibbs | Detroit Lions |
| Best Wide Receiver | Jaxon Smith-Njigba | Seattle Seahawks |
| Best Tight End | *Trey McBride | Arizona Cardinals |
| Best Offensive Lineman | Quenton Nelson | Indianapolis Colts |
| Best Offensive Line | *Denver Broncos |
| Best Defensive Lineman | *Myles Garrett | Cleveland Browns |
| Best Linebacker | Nik Bonitto | Denver Broncos |
| Best Defensive Back | Quinyon Mitchell | Philadelphia Eagles |
| Best Kicker | Cam Little | Jacksonville Jaguars |
| Best Punter | Michael Dickson | Seattle Seahawks |
| Best Return Specialist | Chimere Dike | Tennessee Titans |
| Best Head Coach | Mike Macdonald | Seattle Seahawks |
| Best Team | Seattle Seahawks | 17-3 |
| Offensive Rookie of the Year | *Tetairoa McMillan | Wide Receiver | Carolina Panthers |
| Defensive Rookie of the Year | Carson Schwesinger | Linebacker | Cleveland Browns |
| Special Teams Rookie of the Year | *Chimere Dike | Return Specialist | Tennessee Titans |
| Comeback Player of the Year | Christian McCaffrey | Running Back | San Francisco 49ers |
| Most Improved Player | Jaxon Smith-Njigba | Wide Receiver | Seattle Seahawks |
| Best Game | Los Angeles Rams @
Seattle Seahawks | Week 16
Dec. 18, 2025 | Seahawks 38
Rams: 37 |
| Best Offense | *Los Angeles Rams |
| Best Defense | Houston Texans |
*Denotes Unanimous Selection
